[ Are the Rich Happy? – Summary
Author: Stephen Leacock
Are the Rich Happy? is a humorous and satirical essay by Stephen Leacock. The author examines the supposed troubles of wealthy people and asks whether they are truly happy. Through irony and exaggeration, he exposes their artificial worries, dissatisfaction and pretence. 4.Are the rich happy.pdf
The Author’s Lack of Information
Leacock begins by saying that he is writing the essay without adequate information because he has never actually met a rich person. Whenever he thinks that he has found one, the person claims to be poor, financially troubled or unable to “keep up with the rich.”
Some people maintain fifteen servants, travel in limousines and purchase expensive hats. Yet they describe themselves as financially “pinched.” This contradiction creates humour and introduces the essay’s central satire.
Nobody Admits to Being Rich
The author knows people earning ten thousand, twenty thousand and even fifty thousand dollars a year. Yet all of them say that their income is insufficient to keep up with rich people.
A wealthy lawyer offers the author what he calls a “plain home dinner,” though three men and two women are required to serve it. The contrast between his luxurious lifestyle and his claim of poverty exposes the false modesty of the wealthy.
Reported Cases of Richness
Though the author cannot personally find any rich people, he hears reports about them.
The caretaker of his building has a supposedly rich cousin in England who works for the South Western Railway and earns ten pounds a week. Similarly, the author’s washerwoman has a rich uncle in Winnipeg who owns a house and sends two daughters to high school.
However, the author cannot confirm these stories. They are only reported cases of wealth.
The Troubles of the Rich
Leacock humorously argues that rich people suffer cruel trials and tragedies unknown to the poor.
When exchange rates fall or the balance of trade becomes unfavourable, the poor remain unconcerned. They can sit comfortably at home or enjoy an inexpensive film. The rich, however, must constantly worry about investments, bank accounts, bonds and financial markets.
Thus, money itself becomes a source of anxiety for wealthy people.
Mr Spugg’s Financial Crisis
The author introduces his wealthy friend, Mr Spugg. His bank account is overdrawn by twenty thousand dollars. Spugg feels upset that the bank has brought the matter to his attention.
To cover the overdraft, he may have to ask his secretary to sell some bonds. The author treats this as a terrible tragedy and compares it with his own overdraft of twenty cents.
Poor people may be forced to sell their furniture, but Spugg suffers the supposedly greater pain of selling bonds from his desk. The comparison is deliberately exaggerated and satirical.
Wealth as a Burden
Mr Spugg is a self-made man who considers his accumulated wealth a heavy burden. He claims that he was happier when he possessed only the simple things of life.
While eating a luxurious nine-course dinner, he says that he would prefer:
- Boiled pork and mashed turnip
- A couple of sausages
- Fried bread
- Simple country food
He drinks champagne but remembers with longing the fresh water from a stream near his father’s farm. He claims that champagne never tasted as good as that water.
The author jokingly suggests that Spugg should lie on the floor of the club and drink soda water from a saucer. Spugg, however, refuses to do so. This reveals that his longing for a simple life is not genuine.
Wealth as Social Service
The author once believed that rich people could simply give away their wealth. He later learns that they consider wealth a burden that must be carried.
According to Spugg, great wealth becomes a form of social service and a solemn trust. He claims that he must use it to brighten the lives of others.
However, the irony is clear. While Spugg speaks at length about helping others:
- A waiter becomes exhausted and falls asleep.
- A chauffeur waits outside in the freezing cold.
- Spugg continues enjoying his comfort and luxury.
His words about social responsibility are therefore empty and hypocritical.
Why Spugg Does Not Give Away His Wealth
The author suggests that Spugg donate his wealth to a college. Spugg refuses because he is not a college-educated man.
The author then mentions the need to provide pensions for elderly professors. Spugg responds that professors are national heroes and that their work is its own reward.
Thus, Spugg finds excuses not to part with his money, though he repeatedly describes wealth as a burden.
The Ashcroft-Fowlers’ Tragedy
The author says that even greater tragedies occur in the residences of rich families. He gives the example of the Ashcroft-Fowlers.
During a luxurious dinner at their home, the author notices that the couple is deeply troubled. Their butler, Meadows, has not yet told them whether he will continue working for them.
After dinner, Mr Fowler reveals the painful truth: Meadows is leaving them because he does not like them. Another servant, Franklin, had already left during the previous winter.
The Ashcroft-Fowlers treat the departure of their butler as a great personal tragedy.
After Meadows leaves, they decide to abandon their house and “rough it” for the winter in a hotel suite containing ten rooms and four bathrooms. Their idea of hardship is itself extremely luxurious, making the situation comic.
Happiness Through Ruin
Leacock says that the lives of the rich are not completely gloomy. Some wealthy people achieve genuine happiness when they are totally ruined.
Once they lose all their money, they apparently become free from financial worries and can possess anything they want. This absurd claim is another example of the author’s irony.
Edward Overjoy
The author sees Edward Overjoy travelling happily in a beautiful car with a well-dressed woman. His friend explains that Overjoy has been completely ruined and has no money left.
The author expects him to sell his expensive car, but he does not because his wife is attached to it. The Overjoys also keep:
- Their magnificent sandstone residence
- Their box at the opera
- Their luxurious possessions
- Edward’s costly seal-lined coat
Though Overjoy is said to be worth almost nothing, he continues to live in great luxury. This contradiction exposes the artificial nature of the rich people’s claims of poverty and ruin.
Humour and Irony
The essay’s humour comes from the contrast between what wealthy people say and how they actually live.
They claim that:
- They are poor while living in luxury.
- Wealth is a burden, but they refuse to give it away.
- They prefer simple food while enjoying expensive meals.
- They are ruined but continue to own cars, mansions and costly clothes.
- They are suffering while being surrounded by servants and comforts.
Leacock pretends to sympathise seriously with these trivial problems. This makes the satire sharper and more entertaining.
Central Idea
Are the Rich Happy? satirises the dissatisfaction, pretence and imaginary troubles of wealthy people. The rich possess comfort and luxury, yet they constantly complain about money and consider minor inconveniences great tragedies.
The essay suggests that wealth does not automatically bring happiness. A person who is never satisfied will continue to feel poor, regardless of how much money or property they possess.]